|
NEWS RELEASE
For immediate release: September
24, 2004
Tolko files bid variation and identifies
important issues for shareholders
Vernon, BC – Tolko Industries Ltd. (Tolko) announced
today that it has formally varied the terms of its offer to purchase
all of the outstanding common shares of Riverside Forest Products
Limited (Riverside). Tolko has reduced the Minimum Tender Condition
currently contained in the offer from 75% to 51%.
Trevor Jähnig, Tolko’s Vice-President of
Finance & CFO said: “In the Notice of Variation, we also
responded to important issues contained in Riverside’s Directors’
Circular and press release of September 14, 2004. We believe it
is vital that all shareholders are fully informed and have access
to balanced information. Issues raised by Riverside in previous
documentation have been evaluated and are reflected in our offer.”
Some of the issues addressed include the following:
1. Comparison with recent transactions
(West Fraser/Weldwood & Canfor/Slocan)
Weldwood is significantly larger and has broader,
more diverse product offerings and is not a comparable company
to Riverside. Also, the comparison of Enterprise Value to EBITDA
multiples using a trailing 12 month EBITDA number do not reflect
the highly cyclical nature of the forest sector where transactions
have occurred at different points in the cycle. Using a more appropriate
method such as the multiple of Enterprise Value to Trend EBITDA
shows that Tolko’s offer is consistent with the multiple
paid on the Slocan transaction. Furthermore, we believe both Weldwood
and Slocan have been consistently stronger performers than Riverside.
2. Riverside’s business or growth
prospects.
Riverside’s recent financial results are not
sustainable as they are being driven by peak of cycle commodity
prices for both lumber and plywood. Looking back across various
commodity price cycles, Riverside has generated a net loss in
four of its last 10 fiscal years.
3. Riverside’s substantial cash on
hand.
The Riverside Directors’ Circular fails to
point out that Riverside has non-investment grade debt outstanding
of $197.0 million which is in excess of Riverside’s current
cash balance.
4. Softwood Duty Refunds
The amount and timing of duty refunds, if any, is
highly speculative.
5. Timber tenure take-back compensation
Riverside estimates that it will receive after-tax
compensation of $28 million ($65/m3 or $100/m3 pre-tax) for timber
tenure take-back from the BC government. The BC government recently
announced they had reached agreement with Weyerhaeuser to pay
$27/m3 (pre-tax) in compensation. Riverside’s estimate assumes
it will receive compensation that is approximately four times
higher than the most recent compensation paid.
6. Access to Riverside’s Data Room
Tolko’s initial request for access to Riverside’s
Data Room was refused. Subsequent to that refusal, access was
offered under terms and conditions Tolko finds unacceptable especially
in light of the fact that we believe we are the most strategic
buyer.
Further details of Tolko’s responses are available
in the Notice of Variation which is filed on SEDAR.
For more information:
Tolko Industries Ltd.
Trevor Jahnig
Vice-President Finance & CFO
Phone: (250) 545-4411
E-mail
Back to News Releases
|